The adults solved the epitaph and found the gold. I believe the manga spells it out, but unless you have the IQ of a fruit fly you should be able to figure it out.Įpisode 7's tea party gets the first part of it right. Beatrice survived the events on the island but killed herself afterwards. Battler survived but has amnesia, he wrote the stories from the third on as a means of coping with the emerging memories, and later as a means of helping Ange deal with her own issues and let her move on with her life. He was found by Ikuko (Featherine) and together they write the episodes from what vague recollections Battler has.īest music. Battler tried to save him/her and washed up on the shore amnesiac. Battler and Yasu escaped by boat and Yasu drowned herself/himself at sea out of guilt. The grown-ups figures the epitaph and received the inheritance but Rudolf and Kyrie got greedy and murdered everyone. She was engaged to George but she/he was panicking due to whatever the fuck was going on with his/her genitals and then Battler came back and she/he was all like 'ah fuck it, I'll let fate decide this one fucking Kinzo style' (which involved possibly blowing up the whole island). Yasu made a 'game' to pass on the inheritance to someone else and maybe get Battler to remember his promise. It's been a while but I clearly remember it was all there. We know exactly what happened in every episode and we know what truly happened, no magic bullshit involved. >they never tell you what the real truth is The second case (the only one I thought up any details for) had a bully of Ange murdered via limbs being torn off and the magical explanation was that Ange commanded the Seven Stakes to kill her, so Battler tried to not only prove how magic wasn't used, but also have Ange be completely innocent of what happened. You had to use both physical evidence and red truths to contradict testimonies and figure out a real, non-magical killer. Not sure who Battler's assistant would've been, but I was leaning towards Jessica. Seeing it as something amusing, Bern drags Battler out of his game to help give the clueless victims a fighting chance.īattler as the 'defense' and Beatrice was the 'prosecutor', with Lamdadelta as the Judge and Virgilia filling in the 'detective' role (I wanted to save Erika as a potential sequel prosecutor). So to quickly take care of their arguments, Witch Trials were set up with the 'defendant' being the victims (who can't remember the exact moments of their deaths for fairness). It would take place sometime between games and the basic plot was that Beatrice and Battler's struggle had inspired more people to deny being killed by magic. Had an idea once for an Umineko/Ace Attorney thing. But at the same time, as someone who helped build the community as it is today, I guess I'm unable to fully suppress my irritation at the way it hasn't developed into the ideal I imagined for it over the years. The way I approach the medium as a whole and what I look for out of eroge/VNs are simply too far removed from the western fanbase's to have any sort of meaningful discourse with people using translations, and I accept that. >Honestly, I shouldn't have even posted in here. This applies to other games as well (Fate and Majikoi, for example) and I suppose to a degree it comes part and parcel with the reality that you guys are exposed to such a tiny slice of what's out there, but when the game in question is something as obviously and majorly flawed as Umineko, I can't help but feel a sense of unease, I guess you could say. The amount of Umineko discussion is one of the reasons people who read untranslated eroge feel so disconnected from the broader western fanbase, and it's not hard to see how stifling this level of obsession can be if you take a step back. >I don't know how the western fanbase continues to put up with Ryuukishi, and I honestly feel that it's damaging to the community as a whole to continue to obsess this much over a single work so long after the fact. The Japanese fanbase refuses to so much as give Ryuukishi the time of the day nowadays for good reason. It's a convoluted mess that reads like it was written by a 12 year old. >Hi, I read the entirety of Umineko as it came out and I feel like I'm being generous when I give it a 4/10. How do you feel about Moogy-denka's sentiments about Umineko?

Umineko when they cry torrent